Sunday , September 24 2017
Home / Cafe Hayek / Quotation of the Day…

Quotation of the Day…

Summary:
… is from page 154 of John Cochrane’s superb 2014 speech “Why and How We Care About Inequality,” which is a chapter in Inequality & Economic Policy: Essays in Memory of Gary Becker (Tom Church, Chris Miller, & John B. Taylor, eds., 2015) (original emphasis): Now, the critique of an increasingly rent-seeking society echoes from both the Left and the libertarians.  Rent-seeking is a big problem.  Cronyism is a big problem.  George Stigler finds a lot to agree with in Joe Stiglitz.  As do Milton Friedman, James Buchanan, and so forth. But now comes the most astounding lack of logic of all.  If the central problem is rent-seeking – abuse of the power of the state – to deliver economic goods to the wealthy and politically powerful, how in the world is more governmen the answer? If we

Topics:
Don Boudreaux considers the following as important: , , ,

This could be interesting, too:

Tyler Durden writes Spain In Crisis: Catalan Police Reject Madrid Takeover, Vow To “Resist”

Tyler Durden writes U.S. B-1B Bombers Fly Just Off Coast Of North Korea: 4 Reasons Why This Time It’s Different

Tyler Durden writes Former Democratic Congresswoman Urges All NFL Players To Kneel During National Anthem

Tyler Durden writes Congress Passed A Bill To Deport Suspected ‘Gang’ Members – There’s Just One Problem

… is from page 154 of John Cochrane’s superb 2014 speech “Why and How We Care About Inequality,” which is a chapter in Inequality & Economic Policy: Essays in Memory of Gary Becker (Tom Church, Chris Miller, & John B. Taylor, eds., 2015) (original emphasis):

Quotation of the Day…Now, the critique of an increasingly rent-seeking society echoes from both the Left and the libertarians.  Rent-seeking is a big problem.  Cronyism is a big problem.  George Stigler finds a lot to agree with in Joe Stiglitz.  As do Milton Friedman, James Buchanan, and so forth.

But now comes the most astounding lack of logic of all.  If the central problem is rent-seeking – abuse of the power of the state – to deliver economic goods to the wealthy and politically powerful, how in the world is more governmen the answer?

If we increase the statutory maximum Federal income tax rate 70% , on top of state and local taxes, estate taxes, payroll taxes, corporate taxes, sales taxes and on and on … will that not simply, dramatically, increase the demand for tax lawyers, lobbyists and loopholes?

If you believe cronyism is the problem, why is the first item on your agenda not to repeal the Dodd Frank act and Obamacare, surely two of the biggest invitations to cronyism of our lifetimes?

DBx: Yes.  And the fact that nearly all proponents of using state power to forcibly ‘redistribute’ income or wealth ignore this reality is powerful evidence that they do not think realistically – that they do not think scientifically – about the matters on which they offer policy advice.  For these proponents, the state is simply assumed to have the potential to overcome the human imperfections that cause real (and imagined) problems in the market; this is to say that, for these proponents, the state is simply assumed to have the potential to be god-like.  That attitude isn’t scientific; it’s religious.

(The original version of Cochrane’s speech is here.)

Comments

Don Boudreaux
He is a professor of economics at George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia. Previously, he was president of the Foundation for Economic Education.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *